I
feel like Hobbes knows a pretty good amount about psychology and human nature,
but He seems tobelieve that man kind is nothing but extremely wicked naturally,
which im not sure I completely agree with. Although morals and ethics differ
from country to country, I wouldn’t be so bold as to say that mankind is always
in a state of war unless theres some sort of higher power controlling us. Hobbes reminds me of Edgar Allen Poe with his
high hopes for mankind (extreme sarcasm).
“when going on a journey, you
arm
yourself, and try not to go alone; when going to sleep,
you
lock your doors; even inside your own house you lock
your
chests; and you do all this when you know that there
are
laws, and armed public officers of the law, to revenge
any
harms that are done to you. Ask yourself: what opinion
do
you have of your fellow subjects when you ride armed?
Of
your fellow citizens when you lock your doors? Of your
children
and servants when you lock your chests? In all
this,
don’t you accuse mankind as much by your actions
as
I do by my words?” (Hobbes 58)
In that statement I take out a
couple different interpretations. First off, Hobbes saying that we do all of these things because
subconsciously we know of man kinds natural wickedness and we do these things
because we are expecting to get killed, beat up, or robbed everywhere we go. I
disagree with what Hobbes says here because we as humans have the capability to
learn from past experiences, and while some people in the world are extremely
wicked, a majority of the people I meet seem to have good intentions in most of
their everyday lives. We do the things that Hobbes mentions because we want to
be prepared in worst case scenario, especially in untouched waters.
I agree 100% about Hobbes being a smart man. i agree with you i dont think we need someone to overlook everything.
ReplyDeleteLike you, I don't agree with Hobbes on his belief that all humans are evil, and out to do harm to others. I believe humans act how they are raised or taught. Human nature depends on our culture, belief system, and our personal experiences. Hobbes was a little off with humans basic behavior.
ReplyDeleteGood job! I always appreciate well thought out criticisms of authors!
ReplyDelete